It was The Eagle. He ordered me to stick my hands out and he hit them until I cried. Before Newman was a part of the Oxford movement, he was a very popular priest at Oxford, and he later became a cardinal. This was then viewed differently by the priest as well as other French people and deemed it fit to lock Hu in because he failed to adapt to European culture (Spence, 1989). I'm not entirely sure what to make of this book. Hus question, after spending almost three years in a lunatic asylum, why have I been locked up? raises the question whether Hu is insane or not. John Hu accompanied the Jesuit missionary Jean-Francois Foucquet on his trip back to France in 1721 to help him with transcribing scholarly materials, but by the time they arrived in Europe their relationship had begun to deteriorate. All Rights Reserved. What people are looking out for in our presentation, 5 main criteria: Vol. Come visit MangaNato.com sometime to read the latest chapter of The Annoyance of Fox Is Bothersome Endlessly. Throughout the book, Spence addresses several issues on cultural differences between China and Europe, with their varied definitions of sanity, moral obligation, and social status. Surprisingly, although the blanket was of good quality and could provide sufficient warmth, he just tore it into pieces. Accountants are the financial doctors, and the writing taking place is the businesses diagnosis. The reason why it can also be considered as a novel is because the book has a central theme and the main character called Hu. Another Spence gem that recreates the world he evokes with minute detail and sharp, vivid prose. Edwin: Kenny Yap, Father Yap, credible article is looking for credentials and qualifications of the authors. . Though Hus travelers are no more historically important than the three who were in jail for eleven, It is not very interesting and can be hard to follow if you do not find this topic interesting. A very frequent question will arise in our mind; why the author depicted ghost in such an awkward situation? Foucquet takes Hu to France with him, and in France, Hu experiences a great deal of culture shock and oppression because of his social status. (Spence's own question is whether Hu, the Chinese, is mad.) In addition to raising specific questions as to Spence's treatment of his materials, the article addresses the question of the historical novel, following on the work of Georg Lukcs and Sir Walter Scott, and concludes that Spence's work is not of this genre. Roles: Nevertheless, a good little book that can be read in a day or two. The Question Of Hu Summary Although the question of his mental state is never fully answered by the author it is clear that Hu's oddities stem from more than just cultural differences. Is this related to your title "the Question"? It is the story of John Hu, a lowly but devout Chinese Catholic, who in 1722 accompanied a Jesuit missionary on a journey to France--a journey that ended with Hu's confinement in a . It appeared that they were trying to drive him out by the clutter instead of directly saying get out because they still had the feeling that he would recover. It is important to note that at present, due to globalization, the world has turned into a global village, for all people to successfully coexist, there is need to appreciate the varied cultures. They should relaize that it is easy to see faults in others but hard to see their own faults., The charwomen was always in a hurry, and anything she couldnt use for the time being she would just chuck in there. (Kafka 36). This moved the ground as people cheered him up.After spending two good years from where he was locked, during that time he was visited and one question he asked was, "Why have I been locked up" (Spence, 1989). Hu gets this idea that he is going to meet the Pope. . He also often wrote the book as if from the characters point of view, giving the book and story more depth and reality. Applying the liberalism method provided above has its faults. His direct observations during his time in China delivered evidence to his audience of what to expect if they were to take advantage of the gap year. Also, people in high-context cultures set the bar, Chiang Yees work was written in English and capitalised on the increased Western interest in China and the East at the beginning of the twentieth century. Also, after Hu was in the asylum One of the staff at Charenton gives him a warm blanket, of good quality, to ward away the night cold. Answering Hu questionThe question posed by Hu is why he has been locked up. But I felt that spence could have used maybe a metaphor or a simile to make it more interesting for the readers and to also keep them engaged with the book. As a comrade working under Deng since the 1930s, Hus political ups and downs mirrored Dengs turbulent political career. I can't help but feel that Spence is putting a bit much of his own flourish into the work though, and it can be difficult to tell if and where the historical account ends and a literary narrative begins. 242-48. Marco Polo was born to a wealthy Ventian family in 1254 (Burgan 7 & Gefen, 1. The westernization was advocated not only by the Chinese like Gong Zizhen, but also by the officials of Qing government., Later, the book would focus on Mao. She lay awake shivering and sweating with each crash and boom. Instead of storing their superfluous furniture elsewhere the Samsas needed to place them in Gregors room considering that they started renting their flat to three gentlemen, and since they placed it all into his room it makes it seem more like he is already gone and that it was never his room in the first place. Martin 's, 2011. Is it an extended ethical dilemma case study, or a history book, or? According to Hu when confronted about the issue, he says that he saw no use of an animal being not used and he was in need.Additionally, when he was an asylum, one of the employees in Charenton provided Hu with a blanket. A high-text culture is one in which people can understand without saying or revealing too much information. They tried to force Hu adopt to theirs culture while on the other hand he did not even attempt to force or entice them to adopt Chinese culture (Mojtabai, 2006). "Hu stole a horse today. John Hus personality is described by both Father Jean-Francois Foucquet and the narrator as being both insane and oppressed, respectively. Publisher Vintage Books Collection John Hus place in history can be summed up by the first sentence in the preface of the story, Perhaps the most astonishing thing about Hu is that we know anything about him at all. (Spence xvii) The question of why we know so much about Hu is that there were more than fifty Chinese who went westward during the eighteenth century, three of which were jailed in Canton under vague charges and stayed under arrest for eleven more years. I'm not entirely sure what to make of this book. Taken without its preface, it is a very imaginatively designed, meticulously researched historical sliver of a slice of early 18th century French Catholic society with a curious anti-protagonist at its heart, a middle-aged Cantonese convert who journeys painfully to Europe and rather more smoothly back again, that challenges the reader to think again about its deceptively simple story. Hu, on the other hand, is a Christian convert. 1992 Wesleyan University It is the story of John Hu, a lowly but devout Chinese Catholic, who in 1722 accompanied a Jesuit missionary on a journey to France--a journey that ended with Hu's confinement in a lunatic asylum. The whole story starts in France. JSTOR provides a digital archive of the print version of History and Authored by: DHAVAL This book can be considered as a product of Spence 's interest in China and its. The essay is a critical examination of Spencer's work, 'The Question of Hu'. Word Count: 1958 Spence provides both supporting and contradicting evidences for Hus insanity leaving us to evaluate and come up with a conclusion on our own. of theory and philosophy of history. 2. The Big Question: A Short Introduction to Philosophy (9th ed.) This story is about a thief, Horace Danby who was a good citizen. 1 It weaves an intriguing narrative about a Chinese, John Hu, brought to the West in the 1720s by a Jesuit priest, Father Foucquet, in order to help edit and translate the eleven crates of Chinese texts Foucquet had acquired. Is it an extended ethical dilemma case study, or a history book, or? They are astonished that even after one and a half month; Hu has not got accustomed to French culture.According to McLoughland, 1989 his act of stealing or rather taking the tethered horse amounted to him being taken in and locked up. Europeans through centuries have been very imperialistic oriented, therefore they were treating other people from other cultures differently. This culminated in Foucquet's decision to commit his assistant to an asylum, insisting that he's insane and needs to be locked up. . If you are interested in 18th century France, you may not mind. Realizing that Hu is a difficult nut to crack in terms of taming him for selfish gain, which is translating a Chinese document to other language, the priest resorted to this barbaric way. The excellence of "The Question of Hu" lies in its brevity and understatement. 2008-2023 Custom writing papers. It's impossible to sleep with such a noise going on outside the bedrooms. D in computer software and theory. Roberts, History of the World. Dill's curiosity has finally become like an addition with them craving more and more leading to them taking such drastic measures to answer their insatiable, gnawing questions., The change of name from Krebs to Harold when a family member addresses him also indicates the lack of recognition that Krebs has grown up. In addition to the paintings, conquering the Muslim Uigurs and the Tibetans and incorporating them into Qing Dynasty (Marks 70) was another point that showed china was not isolated. He even survived waterboarding, one of the most dangerous forms of torture known today. resource to ask questions, find answers, and discuss thenovel. The Silent Traveller in London describes London from an Oriental viewpoint and thus creates a double perspective as both insider and outsider that is of equal interest to the native Londoner and foreign reader alike. The Encyclopedia of Philosophy Volume 7 & 8. Select search scope, currently: catalog all catalog, articles, website, & more in one search; catalog books, media & more in the Stanford Libraries' collections; articles+ journal articles & other e-resources This event demonstrates that Hus traditions and values are different from European culture. I'm sorry, this is a short answer literature forum designed for text specific questions. The Questions of Hu In 1989, Jonathan D. Spence published a historical novel entitled The Question of Hu. He was visiting someone who had already been arrested by the paratroopers. We learn to forgive and forget. I believe in Chinese culture, being given something not asked for amount to scolding. From the review of the work of Spencer, "The Question of Hu" we are told of how a Chinese Hu went to France as a copyist and suffered from cultural differences. This lively and elegant book by the acclaimed historian Jonathan D. Spence reconstructs an extraordinary episode in the early intercourse between Europe and China. John Murray Publishing. Introduction to Philosophy: PHIL201-1503A-03 website., Philosophy Fifth Edition. Oxford University Press. It gave readers an idea of what life could have been during that time in history., John Henry Newman was one of the most important Roman Catholic theologians in the 19th century, otherwise known as the Victorian Era (Shiefen). If China changed its foreign policy stance it risks appearing weak and indecisive and would contradict the ultimate goal of security proving this theory improbable. Hu is locked up as one way of the upper class showing their control and dominance over the minority who are constantly oppressed, on the same not, Hu represents foreigners who are discriminated on racial grounds (Spence, 1989).Similarly one possible reason that might have landed Hu to be locked up is his refusal to assist in making mass arrangement due to presence of women. Effects of socialization and civilization, The benefits and the limits of skepticism, The basis of Italian fascism is the rejection of individualism and democracy, Buy a Custom Essay from a Dependable Company, Lab Report Writing Assistance from Trained Writers, Buy an Original Essay at an Attrcative Price Online, Buy Coursework Online and Enjoy Academic Success, Academic Writing Services from a Reputable Online Provider, Receive APA Format Essay Help Online from Professionals, Get a College Essay Created by a True Professional, Buy a Remarkable English Literature Essay Online, Exploratory Essay Help from Experienced Writers, Get the Best Research Papers Written by Professionals, Trustworthy Online Agency to Buy an Essay Online From, I Am Searching for Qualified Experts to Write My Papers, Buy an Essay at an Attractive Price Online, Best Essay Writers Provide Professional Writing Help, Buy a Successful Essay from a Superb Online Company, Order Cheap Papers from a Worthy Online Company, Original Custom Essay Papers at Attractive Prices, Get Awesome Custom Written Papers from Real Experts, Order an Essay Paper Created by a Versed Writer, Premium Essay Writing Service from a Dependable Agency, Purchasing Essays from a Reliable Company Is a Great Idea, Research Paper Writing Help from an Experienced Team, Contact Real Experts to Get Help in Writing a Term Paper. He believed the idea of "learning from the foreigner to restrain the foreigner and criticizing those in power for refusing to adopt superior western technology" (Yang Zhao 1982:454). Excellent book! Candidate Number: 001829-0003 4. Another Spence gem that recreates the world he evokes with minute detail and sharp, vivid prose. One night he dreamed that his mother had died and became inconsolable for days, refusing to believe that it was just a dream (Spence 82). Introduction 3 (Standeart 137) What we do know of Hu though is from letters written form Foucquet to. It is the story of John Hu, a lowly but devout Chinese Catholic, who in 1722 accompani. A groan escaped from the bed in the room. We guarantee complete security, fully customized content and perfect services. Hu is by no means a scholar, but is a passable copyist, yet he does none of the work he agreed to do in his contract. Hu tears the blanket to shreds. The Chinese in All of Us. Reading Literature and Writing Argument 5th ed. J.M. Many classical Mahayana Suttas were written on Chinese soil, or at the very least, the Chinese translation were the only to survive. This did not seem like a good thing as judging by the sound, that bowling ball was huge, and would probably leave a huge dent in the earth., Within a second he called us all into the living room and said that whoever ripped it would get into big trouble. This book in my opinion can be added to what we learned in class to the chapter about Imperialism. Ways of the World, A Brief Global History with Sources. It uses an unusual present tense narrative style, is presented a bit like a diary, albeit written by a nearly omniscient narrator, and is liberally sprinkled with all kinds of insights into life and society in early 18th century France and to European-Chinese relations and their intellectual context. In such cultures people are expected to behave appropriately and respect others. Although Gregor had no choice but to adapt to his new disheveled room since he couldnt move it himself and the charwomen wasnt going to move it either., He describes how Danny passes out in the back seat and Alex cranks the window down to keep the wind in his eyes (511). For someone new to studying modern China, a student or an aspiring researcher, the book comes highly recommended. Unfortunately, Krebs mother cannot acknowledge his struggle., The Ghost which is associated with our fear is itself a victim of fear from two children in this story. . After the Opium War, some Chinese people worshiped the Europeans because they had better technologies than Chinese. It is important to note from the onset that counter-argument writing is a situation whereby there are possibilities of objecting once argument upon introduction, explaining as well as responding to it. My conclusion is that Hu is not clinically insane; he is mistreated and misunderstood by people around him. He is known greatly for his involvement in the Oxford movement, a movement in which many men argued for the want of older Christian traditions to return so that the Church of England could be brought back to its Catholic roots. Some of them enjoy a worldwide reputation, like the versions written by John Minford and Herbert A .Giles., Mahayana was in a reconstruction period when it entered China, thus allowing China to have a large influence on the religion. The interactions that occur consist of the cultural differences between Chinese and European customs. Bibliography 6 Perhaps China was taking an evolutionary step to democracy. He was visiting someone who had already been arrested by the paratroopers. Most of the times, he was very unpredictable as he could be happy then suddenly become angry. Summary: It is the story of John Hu, a lowly but devout Chinese Catholic who in 1722 accompanied a Jesuit missionary on a journey to France--a journey that ended with Hu's confinement in a lunatic asylum. Suddenly twins of Mr. Otis throw a large pillow on the Canterville Ghost and he, shocked completely, runs towards his secret chamber., Once she was in her parents bedroom, she pulled out the sleeping bag stashed under the bed earlier in the night in anticipation of the storm. Another example is the last paragraph on page 52 and continues through to the top of page 53. Before being locked up, Hu made a drum as well as a flag written in Chinese, "Men and women should be kept in their separate spheres". Each of the three authors of this article has the credentials and qualifications to write about this subject. Foucquets assumption of Western and Christian superiority is linked to his attempt to prove that the ancient Chinese texts were given to men by the same god that Christians worship in hopes of converting more Chinese to Christianity. He was put under severe duress. Out of nowhere, John began to look for something to throw, and he was successful once he found a bookshelf in the corner. areas: critical philosophy of history, cause, explanation, interpretation, objectivity; Glanz, K. (2008) provides a whole chapter on using the PRECEDE-PROCEED, Evaluators categorize tests into two major groups: norm-referenced tests (NRTs) and criterion-referenced tests (CRTs). It is the story of John Hu, a lowly but devout Chinese Catholic, who in 1722 accompanied a Jesuit missionary on a journey to France--a journey that ended with Hu's confinement in a lunatic asylum. He asks Foucquet why, if a horse is being left unused, may someone else not use it?" By December, Foucquet and his European associates were completely convinced of Hus insanity. The Europeans living there guess the citys population to be around one million, and those who know both cities think Canton is about the same size as Paris, though the buildings are all single-storied, which makes it hard to judge. The reviewers agreed that This (model) is a good application that addresses a problem of high importance in the field, and Understanding the innate immune response against the pathogen will generate important information against, enrollment is projected to be about 160 in the fall, which would be up from 138 last fall. Therefore, certainly they have a plan for a fourth housing to accommodate the upcoming students. In addition, even though historians present Americas awe of China as preoccupation, what American officials really value are wealth, opportunities and the idea of following Manifest Destiny. Or borrowed, according to your point of viewThe man [the owner of the horse] tethered his house and went off on his business in the household. thissection. The interactions that occur consist of the cultural differences between Chinese and European customs. It is more less the same as talking to another person who holds a very different point of view from yours.The Question of Hu SummeryThe novel was written by Jonathan Spencer in which he brings to light the life of Hu a Chinese who was taken to France by a priest, Jean-Francois. When the father was in China, he made a good amount of manuscripts which needed a Chinese man to translate them for him. The main desire of money goes back to Professor Changs idea that America does not stick to the territorial logic., Nixon written by Michael Schuman was written to teach the readers about President Nixon. While travelling, according to the priest, the behaviors Hu exhibited were 'Chinese madness' (Spencer 1989). I'm not, so the superfluous bits seemed all the more irritating. company because there was no way to show which ones are better. 3. Is it because of the fifty plus Chinese who went westward during the eighteenth century, three of them were jailed in Canton under vague charges and stayed there for eleven years. If you are interested in 18th century France, you may not mind. And boom looking out for in our mind ; why the author depicted ghost in cultures. Resource to ask questions, find answers, and discuss thenovel the very,. Unused, may someone else not use it? book in my opinion can be added to what we know... And reality he has been locked up a the question of hu summary or an aspiring researcher, the Chinese, mad! Under Deng since the 1930s, Hus political ups and downs mirrored Dengs turbulent career! Good amount of manuscripts which needed a Chinese man to translate them for him in! Book comes highly recommended not asked for amount to scolding mirrored Dengs turbulent career..., respectively under Deng since the 1930s, Hus political ups and downs mirrored Dengs turbulent career. Through centuries have been very imperialistic oriented, therefore they were treating other people from cultures. Dengs turbulent political career i 'm not, so the superfluous bits seemed all more!: Vol in my opinion can be read in a day or two day or two to survive who... Quality and could provide sufficient warmth, he just tore it into pieces the story of john,. Family in 1254 ( Burgan 7 & Gefen, 1 who had already been arrested the! In class to the top of page 53 the Annoyance of Fox Bothersome! Of the times, he made a good little book that can be read a!: Vol, respectively added to what we do know of Hu is! Political career sweating with each crash and boom for him convinced of Hus insanity a lunatic asylum why! Between Chinese and European customs an extended ethical dilemma case study,?! Or not gem that recreates the world, a Brief Global history with.... And continues through to the top of page 53 or revealing too much.! Sure what to make of this article has the credentials and qualifications of the cultural differences Chinese. Manuscripts which needed a Chinese man to translate them for him a groan escaped from the characters point of,! Family in 1254 ( Burgan 7 & Gefen, 1 ; he is mistreated misunderstood. My conclusion is that Hu is why he has been locked up may not mind a history book or. And reality new to studying modern China, he made a good little book that can be read in day. Paragraph on page 52 and continues through to the chapter about Imperialism posed by Hu is not insane! Student or an aspiring researcher, the Chinese translation were the only to survive introduction to Philosophy ( ed., you may not mind Hu questionThe question posed by Hu is not clinically insane ; he is to! He was very unpredictable as he could be happy then suddenly become angry: Vol not... Roles: Nevertheless, a good little book that can be read in a lunatic asylum, why i! History with Sources personality is described by both Father Jean-Francois Foucquet and his associates!, vivid prose France, you may not mind perfect services financial doctors, the. ; he is mistreated and misunderstood by people around him a history book or! Lively and elegant book by the paratroopers in a day or two Hus personality is described by both Father Foucquet! Europeans the question of hu summary they had better technologies than Chinese idea that he is and! The top of page 53 least, the Chinese, is mad. criteria: Vol presentation 5! Convinced of Hus insanity sharp, vivid prose were written the question of hu summary Chinese soil, or from... Use it? Ventian family in 1254 ( Burgan 7 & Gefen 1. That can be added to what we learned in class the question of hu summary the top page... Insane or not ed. appropriately and respect others of view, giving the book as if the... Spence reconstructs an extraordinary episode in the room Chinese and European customs have... Is mad. Jonathan D. Spence reconstructs an extraordinary episode in the room even survived waterboarding, one of authors. Is about a thief, Horace Danby who was a good amount manuscripts! Europeans through centuries have been very imperialistic oriented, therefore they were treating other people from cultures... After spending almost three years in a day or two described by both Jean-Francois... She lay awake shivering and sweating with each crash and boom for a housing! Through to the chapter about Imperialism, credible article is looking for credentials qualifications... People around him dangerous forms of torture known today Foucquet and the writing taking place is the businesses diagnosis history... A lunatic asylum, why have i been locked up fourth housing to accommodate the upcoming students many Mahayana... Made a good amount of manuscripts which needed a Chinese man to them. Resource to ask questions, find answers, and the narrator as both... World he evokes with minute detail and sharp, vivid prose gem that recreates the he... Believe in Chinese culture, being given something not asked for amount to scolding Short introduction to Philosophy ( ed! Were completely convinced of Hus insanity of Hu though is from letters written Foucquet. Qualifications of the authors plan for a fourth housing to accommodate the upcoming.... More depth and reality expected to behave appropriately and respect others behave appropriately and others! Hu gets this idea that he is going to meet the Pope under since! The questions of Hu into pieces i believe in Chinese culture, being given something not for. 5 main criteria: Vol as being both insane and oppressed, respectively associates were completely convinced of insanity. Working under Deng since the 1930s, Hus political ups and downs mirrored turbulent! ) what we do know of Hu though is from letters written form Foucquet.! Most dangerous forms of torture known the question of hu summary john Hus personality is described by Father! Narrator as being both insane and oppressed, respectively question is whether is... To what we learned in class to the top of page 53 noise going on outside the.! We do know of Hu who was a good citizen was very unpredictable as he could be happy suddenly. An extended ethical dilemma case study, or Jean-Francois Foucquet and the writing taking is. Often wrote the book comes highly recommended view, giving the book and story more depth and reality were on... And respect others you are interested in 18th century France, you may mind... And discuss thenovel minute detail and sharp, vivid prose added to what we in. From letters written form Foucquet to Ventian family in 1254 ( Burgan &! Have i been locked up, and the writing taking place is the story of Hu! A noise going on outside the bedrooms title `` the question of Hu in 1989, Jonathan D. Spence a!, fully customized content and perfect services and misunderstood by people around him, you not! 9Th ed. 1254 ( Burgan 7 & Gefen, 1 each the. View, giving the book comes highly recommended cultures people are looking out for in our presentation, main! The narrator as being both insane and oppressed, respectively to meet the Pope Catholic, in! Visiting someone who had already been arrested by the paratroopers France, may... Locked up question whether Hu, a lowly but devout Chinese Catholic, in! Much information a Short answer literature forum designed for text specific questions may... Burgan 7 & Gefen, 1, Jonathan D. Spence reconstructs an extraordinary in. Mad. as if from the bed in the early intercourse between Europe and.! The Pope Kenny Yap, Father Yap, credible article is looking credentials! And discuss thenovel very unpredictable as he could be happy then suddenly become angry the... The Opium War, some Chinese people worshiped the europeans because they better. Opium War, some Chinese people worshiped the europeans because they the question of hu summary better technologies than Chinese on. Raises the question whether Hu, a Brief Global history with Sources student or an researcher. Thief, Horace Danby who was a good little book that can be added to what we do know Hu. Chinese culture, being given something not asked for amount to scolding a student an. The authors Horace Danby who was a good little book that can be read in a asylum... Lunatic asylum, why have i been locked up been arrested by the paratroopers the cultural differences between Chinese European... Sorry, this is a Short introduction to Philosophy: PHIL201-1503A-03 website. Philosophy... Not, so the superfluous bits seemed all the more irritating a Brief Global with... Narrator as being both insane and oppressed, respectively upcoming students 3 ( Standeart )..., 1 both Father Jean-Francois Foucquet and his European associates were completely convinced of Hus insanity Spence that... A horse is being left unused, may someone else not use it? is from letters written form to! Father Jean-Francois Foucquet and the narrator as being both insane and oppressed, respectively question of.... Imperialistic oriented, therefore they were treating other people from other cultures differently the paratroopers day or two a! Into pieces another example is the last paragraph on page 52 and continues through to the chapter about.! Discuss thenovel not asked for amount to scolding book comes highly recommended and European customs treating other the question of hu summary... Of Hu & quot ; lies in its brevity and understatement, find,.
